Cook and Hammack preferred +25 bp; the majority held.
Below the old +9.9 peak: October was a pause, not another hike.
Cook and Hammack preferred a 25 bp increase on 28 October.
Released 10 November. Headline/core annual changes are unavailable, not estimated.
October minutes expected 18 November; October PPI due 13 November, 21:30 HKT.
Latest Review: 13 November 2026, 15:00 HKT
13 Nov: October 10-2 hold, both hike dissenters, September PCE, October jobs/CPI and November Waller/Bowman remarks remain incorporated. October PPI is due 21:30 HKT today; minutes expected 18 Nov.
Retain +9.6. No unreleased PPI, new SEP or October minutes assumed; larger-hike discussion is an individual conditional view, not Committee guidance. Review date is separate from the policy or data event date.
Score History
| Current score | Score updated | Previous score | Previous score updated |
|---|---|---|---|
| +9.6 | 10 Nov 2026 | +9.1 | 6 Nov 2026 |
"Score updated" is the policy event, minutes release, or forecast vintage used for the current score. "Previous score updated" is the immediately prior scored event in this dashboard.
Bias Score Time Series
Readout
Score Drivers
| Component | Score | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Inherited stance | +1.5 | September tightening remains in force; October delivered no additional hike. |
| Hawkish dissents | +1.0 | Cook and Hammack preferred a 25 bp increase. |
| Inflation persistence | +2.4 | Core CPI remains 0.3% monthly; core PCE is above target. |
| Waller reaction function | +2.5 | December hike preference, with a conditional case for considering 50 bp; individual view only. |
| Growth and labour | +1.6 | Solid payrolls and stable unemployment reduce near-term easing urgency. |
| September SEP path | +1.3 | 4.1% end-2026/2027 median retained as a dated projection, not fresh guidance. |
| Pause / risk offsets | -0.7 | Majority waited; Warsh avoids pre-commitment and Bowman watches tighter financial conditions. |
Meeting Scorecard
| Event | Action | Signal | Bias score | Read |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17 Jun 2026 | Hold at 3.50-3.75% | Hawkish SEP and press-conference reset. | +7.0 | Very hawkish hold |
| 8 Jul 2026 | June minutes | Live hike case and concern policy might not be restrictive enough. | +7.6 | Hawkish validation |
| 29 Jul 2026 | Hold at 3.50-3.75% | 9-3 vote; three wanted a hike and Warsh reinforced the 2% commitment. | +8.2 | Very hawkish hold |
| 19 Aug 2026 | July minutes | Several favoured a hike; many saw tightening as likely if inflation did not decline. | +8.6 | Very hawkish validation |
| 28 Aug 2026 | Jackson Hole keynote | Warsh said the economy strengthened and summer inflation had not meaningfully improved the underlying trend. | +8.9 | Very hawkish Jackson Hole |
| 11 Sep 2026 | August data | Headline CPI accelerated to 3.4%; payrolls rose 162,000 and unemployment held at 4.1%. | +8.9 | Very hawkish validation |
| 16 Sep 2026 | +25 bp to 3.75-4.00% | Unanimous hike; end-2026 rate median raised to 4.1%, with stronger growth and higher inflation forecasts. | +9.6 | Exceptionally hawkish hike |
| 7 Oct 2026 | September minutes | All backed the hike; most saw another increase by year-end and several judged policy not or only mildly restrictive. | +9.9 | Exceptionally hawkish validation |
| 14 Oct 2026 | September CPI | Headline rose 0.6% monthly and 3.7% yearly; core rose 0.3% and 2.6%, validating continued restraint. | +9.9 | Hot inflation validation |
| 15 Oct 2026 | September PPI | Final demand rose 1.3% monthly and 6.3% yearly; goods rose 2.6% and services 0.8%. | +9.9 | Hot pipeline inflation |
| 28 Oct 2026 | Hold at 3.75-4.00% | 10-2; Cook and Hammack preferred +25 bp. Strong activity, elevated inflation, but majority waited for information. | +8.8 | Hawkish pause; two hike dissents |
| 29 Oct 2026 | September PCE | Headline +0.5% monthly / 3.6% yearly; core +0.3% / 3.1%; real spending broadly flat. | +9.0 | Persistent inflation |
| 6 Nov 2026 | October employment | Payrolls +165,000; unemployment 4.1%; hourly earnings +0.4% monthly / 3.1% yearly. | +9.1 | Stable labour validation |
| 10 Nov 2026 | October CPI / Waller / Bowman | Core CPI +0.3% monthly; Waller's conditional 50 bp case becomes relevant. Bowman notes persistent inflation but financial risks remain. | +9.6 | Very hawkish December risk |
Forecasts / Projection Table
| Item | September SEP | June SEP | Bias implication |
|---|---|---|---|
| GDP growth | 2.3% in 2026 and 2.4% in 2027. | 2.2% and 2.3%. | Stronger growth gives room to tighten. |
| Unemployment | 4.1% in 2026-28. | 4.3%, 4.3% and 4.2%. | Less slack is hawkish. |
| Headline PCE | 3.7% in 2026, 2.3% in 2027 and 2.1% in 2028. | 3.6%, 2.3% and 2.0%. | Near- and medium-term revisions are hawkish. |
| Core PCE | 3.4% in 2026, 2.5% in 2027 and 2.2% in 2028. | 3.3%, 2.5% and 2.1%. | Persistent underlying pressure supports restriction. |
| Policy path | 4.1% in 2026 and 2027, 3.9% in 2028 and 3.6% in 2029. | 3.8%, 3.6% and 3.4% through 2028. | A substantially higher-for-longer path is the strongest hawkish forecast signal. |
These remain September SEP projections versus June, not October or November forecasts. October had no SEP. The 4.1% end-2026/2027 median is a participant projection, not a promised December outcome. Bowman's 10 November estimate of 3.3% October core PCE is an individual nowcast, not released BEA data; October PCE is due 25 November.
Hawkish / Dovish Phrase Audit
His pre-release condition was around 0.3% core CPI or higher; the reported monthly result was 0.3%. This does not establish Committee consensus.
October core CPI matched August and September's monthly pace.
Her October core PCE nowcast was 3.3%; it is not an official BEA release.
Warsh declined to pre-judge December; Bowman weighs tighter financial conditions and AI-investment risks.
Operational reserve management is separate from the policy-rate stance.
Previous Meeting, Consensus, And Press Detail
| Area | Latest verified evidence | Comparison / limitation | Bias implication |
|---|---|---|---|
| Decision / vote | 28 October: 10-2 hold; Cook and Hammack preferred +25 bp. | September: unanimous +25 bp hike. | A hawkish pause, not consecutive delivered tightening. |
| Chair / press conference | Warsh stressed price stability but would not pre-judge December; conditions tighter, not tight. | September SEP remains the latest projection vintage. | Strong inflation focus, less near-term commitment than the old score implied. |
| Waller | 10 November: favours +25 bp in December; would consider +50 bp with core CPI around 0.3% or higher. | Remarks preceded CPI, which then printed 0.3% core. | Conditional larger-hike risk is an inference, not a Committee decision. |
| Bowman | Persistent/broadening inflation; sees October core PCE near 3.3%; watches tighter financial conditions. | Individual nowcast, not official October PCE or a new SEP. | More inflation concern, balanced by financial and investment risks. |
| CPI / annual-data gap | October headline/core +0.4%/+0.3% monthly; annual headline/core unavailable. | September monthly headline/core +0.6%/+0.3%; missing October 2025 indexes prevent annual comparison. | Headline eased, underlying monthly pace did not. |
| PCE source check | BEA September headline/core: 3.6%/3.1% yearly; +0.5%/+0.3% monthly. | Waller cited 3.7% headline in his speech; this dashboard uses BEA's published 3.6%. | Prefer the statistical release for the observed figure; preserve the speech's qualitative signal. |
| Labour | October payrolls +165,000, unemployment 4.1%; wages +0.4% monthly and 3.1% yearly. | Low hiring/firing, rising long-term unemployment and soft housing remain offsets. | Stable employment supports restraint without proving an overheated labour market. |
| Implementation | IORB 3.90%; standing repo 4.00%; reverse repo 3.75%; ample-reserve operations and reinvestments continue. | Operational implementation, not another rate cut or a fresh QE judgment. | No separate score impulse from routine reserve management. |
| Next evidence | October PPI 13 Nov 21:30 HKT; minutes expected 18 Nov; October PCE 25 Nov; next policy decision 9 Dec. | PPI and October minutes were unreleased at this review cutoff. | Do not score future data or invent a meeting outcome. |
Systematic Bias Checklist
Score the action first: hold, hike, cut, vote split, and whether markets expected it.
Compare current official forecasts with the previous forecast vintage. Mark missing forecast meetings explicitly.
Grade phrases on inflation persistence, growth slack, currency, financial stability, and path guidance.
Sources Checked
| Source | Used for | Link |
|---|---|---|
| Federal Reserve October statement | 10-2 hold and named hike dissenters. | 28 October statement |
| October press-conference transcript | Chair's conditional guidance, financial conditions and explanation of the pause. | Official transcript |
| October implementation note | Operating rates and ample-reserve instructions. | October implementation |
| Waller 10 November speech | December hike preference and conditional 50 bp discussion before CPI. | Waller speech |
| Bowman 10 November speech | Inflation persistence, individual PCE nowcast and financial-risk offsets. | Bowman speech |
| BEA September PCE | Observed headline/core prices and release date for October PCE. | BEA September PCE |
| BLS October CPI | Monthly CPI and explanation of missing annual comparisons. | BLS October CPI |
| BLS October employment | Payrolls, unemployment, wages and revisions. | BLS October jobs |
| BLS November release calendar | October PPI scheduled 13 November at 08:30 EST (21:30 HKT). | BLS calendar |
| Fed 2026 speech index | Latest remarks checked through Barr's 12 November AI/inequality speech; no new rate decision. | Fed speech index |
| Federal Reserve September statement | 25 bp hike, unanimous vote and economic/inflation assessment. | Fed statement |
| September Summary of Economic Projections | Rate path, GDP, unemployment and inflation forecasts versus June. | Fed projections |
| September implementation note | Operating rates and balance-sheet implementation details. | Fed implementation note |
| September FOMC minutes | Participant support, year-end rate path, inflation risk management and views on restrictiveness. | Fed September minutes |
| BLS September 2026 CPI | Historical monthly and annual readings, not the latest October data. | BLS September CPI |
| BLS September 2026 PPI | Official final-demand, goods, services and less-food-energy-trade readings. | BLS September PPI |
| FOMC calendar | Completed October decision, no posted October minutes at cutoff, and 8-9 December meeting with projections. | FOMC calendar |
| Review source | Official index, calendar or remarks checked as of this bank's stated review date. | Review source |
Reviewed 13 November 2026, 15:00 HKT. Scores are analytical assessments on a -10 to +10 scale. Market-consensus rows use reputable recaps where official releases do not publish expectations.