All ultimately supported the October hold.
Waiting, not another delivered hike; later inflation validates restraint.
MRO 2.65%; marginal lending 2.90%.
Energy 20.8%; services 3.3%.
October account expected 26 November.
Latest Review: 13 November 2026, 15:00 HKT
29 Oct unanimous hold and Q&A; 4 Nov Eurostat flash October HICP 4.0%, core 2.5%; next decision 17 Dec, account expected 26 Nov.
Set +9.0: hawkish optionality and energy pressure, but no delivered October hike and unchanged core inflation. Review date is separate from the policy or data event date.
Score History
| Current score | Score updated | Previous score | Previous score updated |
|---|---|---|---|
| +9.0 | 4 Nov 2026 | +8.8 | 29 Oct 2026 |
"Score updated" is the policy event, minutes release, or forecast vintage used for the current score. "Previous score updated" is the immediately prior scored event in this dashboard.
Bias Score Time Series
Readout
Score Drivers
| Component | Score | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Inflation level | +2.6 | Headline 4%, with elevated energy. |
| Further-tightening direction | +2.4 | Conditional guidance in the press conference. |
| Hike discussion | +1.3 | Some considered an increase before unanimous hold. |
| September projections | +1.5 | Above-target forecast path remains relevant. |
| Policy inheritance | +1.7 | Earlier tightening remains in place. |
| Core / financing offsets | -0.5 | Core unchanged and longer-term financing tighter. |
Meeting Scorecard
| Event | Action | Language / forecast comparison | Bias score | Read |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30 Apr 2026 | Rates held at 2.00% deposit rate | Pressure was building, but the ECB waited for more data. | +2.4 | Hawkish lean |
| 11 Jun 2026 | +25 bp hike to 2.25% | First hike since 2023; energy shock and above-target inflation outweighed weaker growth. | +7.4 | Strong hawkish hike |
| 18 Jun 2026 | Lane post-meeting validation | The chief economist defended the hike even after energy prices eased. | +7.4 | Hawkish validation |
| 23 Jul 2026 | Rates held; deposit rate 2.25% | Unanimous hold, but some governors considered a hike; upside inflation risks and energy propagation keep tightening optionality live. | +5.8 | Strong hawkish hold |
| 27 Aug 2026 | July account | Some members would not have opposed a hike; another increase is likely unless inflation improves significantly. | +6.5 | Hawkish account |
| 10 Sep 2026 | +25 bp; deposit rate 2.50% | Second 2026 hike; August inflation 3.3% and 2027-28 staff inflation forecasts revised higher. | +8.5 | Very hawkish hike |
| 2 Oct 2026 | September flash HICP | Headline inflation accelerated to 3.8%; energy reached 18.8%, services 3.2% and ex-food-and-energy 2.5%. | +9.2 | Hot inflation validation |
| 8 Oct 2026 | September meeting account | All members backed the hike; it was robust across all scenarios, with core inflation above 2% throughout the horizon. | +9.4 | Very hawkish unanimous validation |
| 23 Oct 2026 | September consumer survey | One-year expectations 3.1% from 3.0%; three-/five-year unchanged at 2.9%/2.5%; growth expectations weaker. | +9.4 | Mixed survey; score unchanged |
| 29 Oct 2026 | Unanimous hold | Deposit rate 2.50%; some considered hiking, but all agreed to wait. | +8.8 | Hawkish pause |
| 4 Nov 2026 | October flash HICP | Headline 4.0%, core 2.5% unchanged; energy-led acceleration validates restraint. | +9.0 | Hawkish pause; energy-led inflation |
Forecasts / Projection Table
| Variable | September meeting read | Previous reference | Bias implication |
|---|---|---|---|
| Headline inflation | September flash HICP accelerated to 3.8%, above the 3.0% 2026 staff average. | August final HICP was 3.2%. | A larger target overshoot is hawkish. |
| Underlying inflation | Ex-food-and-energy inflation rose to 2.5%; services reached 3.2%. | August ex-food-and-energy was 2.4% and services 3.0%. | Broader persistence supports tightening. |
| Energy shock | September energy inflation accelerated to 18.8%. | August energy inflation was 14.3%. | Stronger propagation risk is hawkish. |
| Growth | Staff project 0.9%, 1.4% and 1.5% growth in 2026-28, with 2026-27 revised up. | June baseline was weaker. | Resilience gives more room to tighten, though risks remain downside. |
| Wages / second round | Wage indicators are moderating and the ECB is not yet seeing second-round effects. | June hike guarded against broader pass-through. | No observed second round is a dovish offset. |
| October inputs | Energy propagation, wages, expectations, activity and credit will inform 29 October. | September delivered a new projection round. | High data dependence keeps the next move open. |
September staff projections remain the formal vintage; October had no forecast round. The 4 November October HICP estimate is observed flash data, not a new ECB forecast. October account expected 26 November; next decision 17 December.
Hawkish / Dovish Phrase Audit
The Q&A gives a direction, not a promised December decision.
Flash HICP 4.0%; core remains 2.5%.
Higher long-term financing costs and growth risks temper the signal.
Previous Meeting, Consensus, And Press Detail
| Area | Latest evidence | Comparison | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rates | 2.50% / 2.65% / 2.90% | Unchanged on 29 October | No new delivered hike. |
| Vote | Unanimous hold; some considered a hike | September unanimously raised rates | Hawkish pause, less forceful action. |
| October flash HICP | 4.0% headline; 2.5% core | September 3.8% / 2.5% | Core stability offsets headline acceleration. |
| Minutes / forecasts | October account pending; September projections retained | Account expected 26 November | Do not infer unpublished deliberations. |
Systematic Bias Checklist
Score the action first: hold, hike, cut, vote split, and whether markets expected it.
Compare current official forecasts with the previous forecast vintage. Mark missing forecast meetings explicitly.
Grade phrases on inflation persistence, growth slack, currency, financial stability, and path guidance.
Sources Checked
| Source | Used for | Link |
|---|---|---|
| ECB October decision | Unchanged rates. | ECB October decision |
| ECB October Q&A | Unanimity, hike discussion and conditional guidance. | ECB October Q&A |
| Eurostat October flash HICP | 4 November release and components. | Eurostat October flash HICP |
| ECB Governing Council calendar | 16-17 December meeting. | ECB Governing Council calendar |
| ECB September Consumer Expectations Survey | 23 October release: one-, three- and five-year expectations and growth backdrop. | ECB consumer survey |
| ECB 10 September monetary policy decision | Official 25 bp increase and new rate levels. | ECB decision |
| ECB September meeting account | Unanimous support, scenario analysis, inflation persistence, upside risks and meeting-by-meeting guidance. | ECB September account |
| ECB September statement and Q&A | Inflation, growth, staff projections, risk balance and reaction function. | ECB statement and Q&A |
| Eurostat September flash inflation | Headline, underlying, services and energy inflation. | Eurostat September HICP |
| ECB Governing Council calendar | Next monetary policy meeting on 28-29 October 2026. | ECB calendar |
| Review source | Official index, calendar or remarks checked as of this bank's stated review date. | Review source |
Reviewed 13 November 2026, 15:00 HKT. Scores are analytical assessments on a -10 to +10 scale. Market-consensus rows use reputable recaps where official releases do not publish expectations.