Both rate dissenters are captured in the 13-2 vote.
Named votes are now verified in the published minutes.
September decision remains the rate anchor.
Separate credit-control vote was 14-1, Lee alone opposed.
Next policy decision 17 December; CPI is observed data.
Latest Review: 13 November 2026, 15:00 HKT
29 Oct Chinese minutes verify 13-2 rate hold (Chen/Lee hike dissents) and separate 14-1 credit easing vote. 5 Nov CPI 2.33%/2.23%; 11 Nov reserve-money release checked. Next 17 Dec.
Retain +4.8; preserve both hike dissenters without double-counting the already captured minority. Reserve money is not a rate cut. Review date is separate from the policy or data event date.
Score History
| Current score | Score updated | Previous score | Previous score updated |
|---|---|---|---|
| +4.8 | 5 Nov 2026 | +4.8 | 29 Oct 2026 |
"Score updated" is the policy event, minutes release, or forecast vintage used for the current score. "Previous score updated" is the immediately prior scored event in this dashboard.
Bias Score Time Series
Readout
Score Drivers
| Component | Score | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Two hike dissents | +1.6 | Both are named and verified. |
| Pipeline / FX risks | +1.3 | Minority concern about pass-through. |
| Growth / inflation inheritance | +1.4 | Stronger earlier forecast package. |
| Core prices | +1.0 | October core 2.23% yearly. |
| Credit / uneven demand | -0.5 | Credit easing and weak domestic spillovers offset. |
Meeting Scorecard
| Meeting | Action | Forecast / language change | Bias score | Read |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 19 Mar 2026 | Rates held | CBC forecast package had lower GDP, CPI, core CPI, M2, and credit assumptions. | +1.8 | Cautious hold |
| 18 Jun 2026 | Rates held | GDP, CPI, core CPI, Brent, M2, and loans/investments were all revised higher. | +3.8 | Neutral-hawkish hold |
| 17 Sep 2026 | Rates held | Two directors supported a hike; forecasts rose and selected credit controls eased. | +4.8 | Hawkish hold |
| 29 Oct 2026 | September minutes published | 13-2 rate hold: Chen and Lee for hikes; separate credit easing 14-1 with Lee opposed. | +4.8 | Two named hike dissenters |
| 5 Nov 2026 | October CPI | Headline 2.33%, core 2.23%; minutes' hawkish minority balanced by majority's demand concerns; score retained. | +4.8 | Hawkish hold; two named dissents |
Forecasts / Projection Table
| Forecast item | September 2026 forecast | June 2026 forecast | Bias implication |
|---|---|---|---|
| October observed CPI | Headline 2.33%; core 2.23% y/y | Monthly +0.06% / +0.54% | Core excludes fruit, vegetables and energy; not a replacement policy forecast. |
| January-October average CPI | Headline 1.98%; core 2.17% | Period average, not October monthly outcome | Keep frequency and period distinct. |
| October reserve money | Daily-average annual growth 6.80% | September 8.03% | Operational aggregate; not a policy-rate cut. |
| Real GDP growth | 11.48% | 9.45% | Another large upgrade removes any growth case for easing. |
| CPI inflation | 2.03% | 1.91% | A move just above 2% is mildly hawkish. |
| Core CPI inflation | 2.16% | 1.90% | Underlying inflation revision is the clearest hawkish price signal. |
| 2027 CPI / core | 1.83% / 1.89% | Not in the June 2026 annual forecast comparison. | Below-2% medium-term path caps rate urgency. |
| M2 growth | 6.60% actual | 6.12% forecast | Ample liquidity supports vigilance. |
| Loans and investments | 8.23% actual | 7.94% forecast | Firm credit growth remains a financial-stability consideration. |
Formal numerical forecasts below retain September's vintage. New October CPI is observed data. The 29 October minutes are the September meeting record; they do not constitute an October rate decision.
Hawkish / Dovish Phrase Audit
14-1 easing vote, with Lee alone opposed.
Hawkish minority arguments remain material.
The majority balances AI strength against weaker household/SME conditions.
Previous Meeting, Consensus, And Press Detail
| Area | Verified latest evidence | Do not confuse with | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rate vote | 13-2; Chen Hsu-sheng and Lee Yi-ting sought hikes | Not unanimous hold | Two hawkish dissents retained. |
| Credit controls | 14-1; Lee opposed easing | Not the rate vote | Separate policy instrument. |
| October CPI | 2.33% headline / 2.23% core | September forecast vintage | New observed price evidence. |
| Reserve money | 6.80% annual growth | A policy-rate decision | No inferred rate cut. |
| Next | 17 December | No new completed rate meeting | Keep 2.00% rate anchor. |
Systematic Bias Checklist
Score the action first: hold, hike, cut, vote split, and whether markets expected it.
Compare current official forecasts with the previous forecast vintage. Mark missing forecast meetings explicitly.
Grade phrases on inflation persistence, growth slack, currency, financial stability, and path guidance.
Sources Checked
| Source | Used for | Link |
|---|---|---|
| CBC September minutes landing page | 29 October publication. | CBC September minutes landing page |
| CBC official minutes PDF | Rate vote and separate credit vote, printed page 15. | CBC official minutes PDF |
| DGBAS October CPI | 5 November prices and exact core definition. | DGBAS October CPI |
| CBC October reserve money | 11 November operational aggregate. | CBC October reserve money |
| CBC meeting calendar | Next 17 December. | CBC meeting calendar |
| CBC September monetary policy decision | Policy rates, growth and inflation forecasts, money and credit data, and credit-control changes. | CBC September decision |
| CNA post-meeting policy Q&A | Governor Yang's confirmation that two directors supported a rate increase. | CNA post-meeting report |
| CBC Chinese press-conference materials | Forecast revisions and meeting communication context. | CBC Chinese site |
| Review source | Official index, calendar or remarks checked as of this bank's stated review date. | Review source |
Reviewed 13 November 2026, 15:00 HKT. Scores are analytical assessments on a -10 to +10 scale. Market-consensus rows use reputable recaps where official releases do not publish expectations.