Takata dissented against the hold.
Higher later inflation and ETF runoff, balanced by mixed pace views.
The September two-hold-dissent pattern is not the October vote.
Book value; effective January 2027, separately agreed unanimously.
October minutes due 23 December; 10 November opinions are not full minutes.
Latest Review: 13 November 2026, 15:00 HKT
30 Oct 8-1 hold, Takata hike dissent, separate ETF-sales decision, October forecasts, 10 Nov opinions and 12 Nov Asada speech checked. Next decision 18 Dec; minutes 23 Dec.
Set +8.9 versus +9.8: still hawkish, but October paused and pace views are mixed. No unanimous faster-hike guidance inferred. Review date is separate from the policy or data event date.
Score History
| Current score | Score updated | Previous score | Previous score updated |
|---|---|---|---|
| +8.9 | 12 Nov 2026 | +9.0 | 30 Oct 2026 |
"Score updated" is the policy event, minutes release, or forecast vintage used for the current score. "Previous score updated" is the immediately prior scored event in this dashboard.
Bias Score Time Series
Readout
Score Drivers
| Component | Score | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Inherited tightening | +2.0 | Prior hikes remain in force. |
| Conditional path | +2.2 | Further normalisation remains the direction. |
| Later inflation forecasts | +2.3 | FY2027 underlying forecasts raised. |
| ETF runoff | +1.3 | Sales accelerate from January, not immediately. |
| Hike dissent | +1.2 | Takata sought 1.50%. |
| Pace / consumption caution | -0.1 | Mixed views and long transmission lags. |
Meeting Scorecard
| Meeting | Action | Language / forecast comparison | Bias score | Read |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30 Apr 2026 | Pause / April Outlook baseline | BoJ watched wages, underlying inflation, and external risks while markets waited for timing. | +2.8 | Hawkish watch |
| 16 Jun 2026 | Hike to 1.00% | Looked through softer spot core CPI and emphasized pass-through / stable 2% inflation. | +6.5 | Hawkish hike |
| 24-25 Jun 2026 | Summary of Opinions / Tamura speech | Post-meeting materials reinforced wage-price path and neutral-rate normalisation; no new decision, but a hawkish validation. | +7.2 | Hawkish validation |
| 31 Jul 2026 | Hold at 1.00% | 8-1 vote; one proposal for 1.25%, upside CPI risks and explicit further-hike guidance. | +7.8 | Very hawkish hold |
| 10 Aug 2026 | Summary of Opinions | Members stressed upside price risks, accommodative conditions and potentially faster hikes. | +8.2 | Very hawkish validation |
| 27 Aug 2026 | Himino speech | Deputy Governor backed continued hikes and warned underlying inflation could move above 2%. | +8.5 | Very hawkish speech |
| 2-10 Sep 2026 | Takata / Masu speeches | Calls for nimble hikes and prompt progress toward a 1.1-2.5% neutral-rate range. | +8.8 | Very hawkish chorus |
| 18 Sep 2026 | Hike to 1.25% | 7-2 vote, upside underlying-inflation risk and explicit continued-hike guidance. | +9.5 | Very hawkish hike + path |
| 1 Oct 2026 | Summary of Opinions | Members discussed timely further hikes, reaching the approximate goal relatively soon and accelerating if prices deviate upward. | +9.8 | Exceptionally hawkish validation |
| 23 Oct 2026 | September national CPI | Headline/ex-fresh-food 2.1%; ex-fresh-food-and-energy 2.4%; Koeda's 15 October guidance also checked. | +9.8 | Hawkish validation; unchanged |
| 30 Oct 2026 | 8-1 hold at 1.25%; ETF runoff accelerated | Takata sought 1.50%; later inflation forecasts raised; ETF sales start January 2027. | +9.0 | Hawkish hold and runoff |
| 12 Nov 2026 | October opinions / Asada remarks | Conditional normalisation but mixed pace; cautious individual remarks balance higher forecast inflation. | +8.9 | Hawkish hold; mixed pace views |
Forecasts / Projection Table
| Fiscal-year medians | October: FY26 / FY27 / FY28 | July: same years | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Real GDP | 0.7% / 0.7% / 0.8% | 0.6% / 0.8% / 0.8% | Higher FY26, lower FY27. |
| CPI excluding fresh food | 2.5% / 2.6% / 2.0% | 2.5% / 2.4% / 2.0% | Higher FY27 persistence. |
| CPI excluding fresh food and energy | 2.4% / 2.7% / 2.3% | 2.5% / 2.6% / 2.2% | Near-term lower, later years higher. |
| Food-tax proposal | Excluded from baseline | Illustrative FY27 impacts: -1.3pp / -1.4pp on the two CPI measures | Scenario, not an implemented tax cut or automatic forecast revision. |
| Policy timing | Continue normalisation conditionally | Opinions contain both faster and cautious views | No unanimous December-hike promise. |
October Outlook replaces July; fiscal-year definitions and CPI exclusions are explicit. Full Outlook published 2 November, opinions 10 November. October meeting minutes remain pending until 23 December. Proposed food-tax impacts are separate scenarios.
Hawkish / Dovish Phrase Audit
JPY860bn/year book value from January 2027, not an immediate rate move.
FY2027 ex-fresh-food CPI rises to 2.6%.
Cumulative tightening and weak consumption remain concerns.
His cautious speech does not establish Board consensus.
Previous Meeting, Consensus, And Press Detail
| Area | Latest evidence | Comparison / status | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rate vote | 8-1 hold; Takata for 1.50% | September 7-2 hike with two hold dissents | Do not carry the prior dissent pattern forward. |
| ETF decision | Unanimous faster sales from January 2027 | Book value JPY330bn to JPY860bn/year | Separate balance-sheet action. |
| Opinions | Published 10 November | Not full minutes; mixed pace views | Conditional normalisation. |
| Asada | 12 November: consumption flat, lags can exceed a year | Individual neutral-range estimate slightly above 1%-2.5% | Cautious offset, not a new decision. |
| Next | 18 December; October minutes 23 December | No new October minutes at cutoff | Do not score future deliberations. |
Systematic Bias Checklist
Score the action first: hold, hike, cut, vote split, and whether markets expected it.
Compare current official forecasts with the previous forecast vintage. Mark missing forecast meetings explicitly.
Grade phrases on inflation persistence, growth slack, currency, financial stability, and path guidance.
Sources Checked
| Source | Used for | Link |
|---|---|---|
| BoJ October decision | Rate vote and separate ETF decision. | BoJ October decision |
| BoJ October Outlook | Fiscal-year medians versus July and tax scenario. | BoJ October Outlook |
| BoJ October opinions | 10 November publication and mixed pace views. | BoJ October opinions |
| Asada 12 November speech | Individual caution about consumption and policy lags. | Asada 12 November speech |
| BoJ schedule | December decision and October minutes dates. | BoJ schedule |
| Statistics Bureau September national CPI | 23 October release, 2025-base headline and exact exclusion definitions. | Official September CPI |
| Koeda 15 October speech | Individual policy-board member's rate-normalisation assessment. | Koeda speech |
| BoJ September Summary of Opinions | Member views on underlying inflation, accommodative conditions, future hikes and possible acceleration. | BoJ September opinions |
| BoJ September policy statement | Official 25 bp hike, 7-2 vote, inflation assessment and continued-hike guidance. | BoJ September statement |
| BoJ July policy statement | 1.00% hold, 8-1 vote and Takata's 1.25% proposal. | BoJ statement |
| BoJ July Outlook Report | Forecasts, upside CPI risk and further-rate-rise guidance. | BoJ Outlook |
| BoJ 10 August Summary of Opinions | Upside price risks, accommodative conditions and the prospective pace of rate hikes. | BoJ Summary of Opinions |
| BoJ Deputy Governor Himino speech | Continued rate increases, upside underlying-inflation risk and the meeting-by-meeting reaction function. | BoJ Himino speech |
| BoJ Takata speech | New-phase inflation assessment and case for nimble rate increases. | BoJ Takata speech |
| BoJ Masu speech | Negative real rates, neutral-rate range and further-hike guidance. | BoJ Masu speech |
| BoJ meeting calendar | Confirmed 29-30 October meeting and release schedule. | BoJ calendar |
| Review source | Official index, calendar or remarks checked as of this bank's stated review date. | Review source |
Reviewed 13 November 2026, 15:00 HKT. Scores are analytical assessments on a -10 to +10 scale. Market-consensus rows use reputable recaps where official releases do not publish expectations.